This is one of the kids' favorite meals ... but I tend to avoid it because I could never get it to come out right. Plus, Mike is a pizza pro, so while I know I can cook many other foods quite well, pizza ... I just am not confident. A regular oven just can't do the same thing as a pizza oven. Mine always comes out underdone, or thick, or just plain not right. So, I experiment on the kids - tonight was a good opportunity; Mike's at a business dinner and we could play. (Side note: Mike would be great about "playing" with pizza and experimenting ... in fact, in all fairness, he'd probably have fun (and make it MORE fun!). I am just too fussy about what I offer him. I'm working on that ...)
So ... I figured out a good "method" that works. I will eventually try making my own dough (it will cost a LOT less than the store pizza dough balls) as well as my own sauce, but until I figured out the timing and temperature, I decided to make things easy, and we used pizza dough from Shaw's, hunt's garlic & cheese sauce, and home shredded mozarella (the bagged stuff never melts right, IMO). Well ... some of us used that. Some of us skipped the sauce (Bren & me) and loaded up on pepperoni, olive oil and seasonings (garlic & basil). Yeah, I know, healthy, right?
Here are the results ... they turned out great, I think. We put these in my 8x8 square pan, and 2 8 inch cake pans. I sprayed with non-stick cooking spray, sprinkled with flour, and then used 1/3 pound of room temperature dough in each. Baked in a pre-heated 500F oven for 5-7 minutes. We removed from the pans and cooled on a cooling rack for about 4 minutes before diving in.
The kids were just a hair frustrated - they really enjoyed using the airbake cookie sheets last time because they could make crazy shapes. While that was fun - I agree about that - they just don't cook the pizza well, they came out really doughy. They all agreed that these tasted much better and they *supposed* it was okay if they made them this way again. (Insert sighing and rolling of eyes.)
Betsy's:

Justin's (left) and Andrew's (right)

Mine (left) and Brendan's (right)

It was fun. I'm sure they'll be bugging me even more often to make this now. :)